An S-trap toilet connects through a floor outlet, while a P-trap model connects through a wall outlet. Neither type is automatically better. The right replacement depends on the existing waste connection, the toilet model's set-out dimensions and whether the plumbing is being altered.
What set-out means
Set-out is the measurement used to position the pan outlet in relation to the finished wall or floor, as specified for a particular model. S-trap models commonly specify the distance from the finished wall to the floor outlet centre. P-trap models specify a wall outlet position and projection. Exact dimensions and allowable adjustment vary by product, so use the manufacturer's current drawing rather than a generic measurement.
Before ordering, confirm the outlet type, position, finished floor height, available space, water inlet location and how the cistern will sit. Also check that the chosen pan can connect to the existing pipework without an unsuitable offset connector. A model that looks similar may have a different set-out and may not fit.
Do not alter the drain as a DIY fix
If the new toilet does not match the existing outlet, do not cut, move or adapt the waste pipe yourself. A change to plumbing or drainage must be assessed and completed by an appropriately licensed plumber, with any approval or notification requirements checked for the specific work.
For a toilet that is leaking rather than being replaced, read how to observe where the leak starts.
Once the fit is confirmed, compare models by their WELS label.
Contact our plumbing team to check a proposed toilet replacement and the existing waste connection before purchase. The compatible model depends on measurements at your property.